Showing posts with label committees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label committees. Show all posts

Saturday, December 24, 2011

India ranked 95 among 183 countries in world corruption index

  •  India's image on tackling graft seems to have gone from bad to worse in the perception of people dealing with the system, with its rank slipping to a low 95 among 183 countries in Transparency International's Corruption Perception Index (CPI).
  • While the debate continues in India over an anti-graft ombudsman, the study by the international watchdog shows the country's image declining consistently over the past three years. This year, the country scores 3.1 on 10, with 10 being the highest score.
  • Since 2007 when India was ranked 72 among 180 countries with a score of 3.5, the score has declined, so have the rankings. Last year, India was placed at 87. The CPI ranks countries based on how corrupt their public sector is perceived to be and is a composite index that draws on data and studies by a number of specialised international agencies through a complex process.
  • India's score is a result of an average of 13 studies including World Bank's Country Performance and Institutional Assessment, World Economic Forum Executive Opinion Survey and Global Insight Country Risk Ratings, among others. New Zealand is at the top spot with a score of 9.5 followed by Finland and Denmark. The countries that occupy the bottom ranks in the index are Somalia, North Korea, Myanmar and Afghanistan, which are helmed in by unstable governments and conflicts.
  • With the unearthing of major scams, arrests of influential people over corruption and a movement for a Lokpal stealing headlines in India, people associated with Transparency International India said since the study is a measurement of perception, these factors could have marginally contributed to the decline.

Monday, August 15, 2011

Prime Minister announces setting up of Education Commission

  • Keen on enhancing the quality of education in the country, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Monday announced the government's decision to appoint a commission to make recommendations in this regard and talked about moves to universalise secondary education.
  • As per the RTE, education is free and compulsory up to eighth standard and universalisation of secondary education will make it free and compulsory up to Class X.
  • Noting that the government had emphasised on education in the 11th Five Year Plan, Dr. Singh said similar priority will be given to the health sector in the 12th Five Year Plan.
  • Dr. Singh said he will propose to the National Development Council that the 12th plan should be specially focused on health.
  • He said government will endeavour to cover as many workers as possible under the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana which was introduced in 2008.

Sunday, March 20, 2011

National Ganga River Basin Authority

  • The Central Government has set up the National Ganga River Basin Authority (NGRBA) in February, 2009 as an empowered authority for conservation of the river Ganga with a river basin approach. The Authority has decided that under Mission Clean Ganga it will be ensured that by 2020 no untreated municipal sewage and industrial effluents flow into Ganga. 
  • Pollution abatement schemes worth about Rs.2476 crores have been sanctioned under NGRBA so far. River conservation projects such as creation of civic infrastructure for sewage management and disposal are also being implemented under other central schemes, such as Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission, Urban Infrastructure Development Scheme for Small and Medium Towns, as well as under State sector schemes. 
  • The pollution load on rivers including Ganga has increased over the years due to rapid urbanization and industrialization. Abstraction of water for irrigation, drinking, industrial use, power etc. compounds the challenge. Disposal of untreated/partially treated sewage by the cities and towns is the major source of pollution in the river, constituting about 75-80% of the pollution loads by volume. As per Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB), 2760 mld (million litres per day) of sewage is generated by the cities and towns along the river. Industrial effluents and other non-point sources of pollution like disposal of dead bodies and animal carcasses, open defecation, cattle wallowing, agricultural runoff etc., add to the pollution loads. 

Tuesday, February 1, 2011

Report of the One Man Committee on 2G Allocation Handed over to the Government

  • A one-man Committee comprising Justice Shivraj V. Patil, retired Judge of the Supreme Court, was set up by the Department of Telecommunications on December 13, 2010 to examine the appropriateness of procedures followed by the Department of Telecommunications in issuance of licences and allocation of spectrum during the period 2001-2009.
Annexure

  1.  To study the circumstances and developments in the Telecom sector that led to the formulation of the New Telecom Policy 1999 and subsequently, introduction of 4th Cellular Telecom Mobile Service (CMTS) licence in 2001
  2. 2. To examine the internal (intra-departmental) procedures adopted by DoT during the period 2001-2009 for
  • Issue of telecom access service licences and
  • Allocation of spectrum to all telecom access services licencees during the above period
3. To examine whether these procedures were in accordance with extant policies and directions ofDoT/Government
4. To examine whether these procedures were followed consistently and if not, identify specific instances of 

  •  Deviation from laid down procedures 
  • Inappropriate application of laid down procedures
  • Violation of underlying principles of laid down procedures

5. To examine whether the procedures adopted were fair and transparent and were in keeping with the principles of natural justice and if not, identify the specific instances of lack of fairness and transparency

6. To identify the deficiencies, if any, in the procedures as formulated and identify the public officials responsible for such deficiencies

7. To identify the shortcomings and lapses, if any, in the implementation of the laid down procedures and identify the public officials responsible for such lapses

8. To suggest remedial measures to avoid in future

  •  Deficiencies in formulation of procedures and 
  • Lapses in implementation of laid-down procedures

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Vaidyanathan committee report

Agriculture plays a very pivotal role in the Indian economy providing employment to half of the population and contributing one-fifth to the GDP. The volatility in this sector has been one of the prime concern of the policy makers. To arrest this volatility and raise the livelihood security of the nation various commissions had been set up in the past. For instance, National Commission On Farmers. Recently the government has set up an expert committee under eminent economist Prof. A Vaidyanathan to look into the issues of raising crop yield through better estimation. The recommendations of the committee are given below.

Vaidyanathan Committee Recommends Remote Sensing, National Centre for Improving Agricultural Statistics
The expert committee set up under the chairmanship of Prof A Vaidyanathan to suggest ways to improve agricultural statistics has called for using remote sensing and restructuring the data collection machinery. In its interim report, the Expert Committee has also recommended setting up of National Crop Statistics Centre (NCSC) to deal with all aspects of crop area and yield estimation.

Details about the Expert Committee and its recommendations are as follows:

In pursuance of recommendations of Steering Committee on Agriculture & Allied Sector for formulation of 11th Five Year Plan set up by Planning Commission for thorough review of Schemes for collection of Agricultural Statistics for bringing about lasting improvements in basic system of agricultural statistics and as per decisions taken in the meeting with National Statistical Commission (NSC), the Government constituted a Committee of Experts to
(a) look into the problems relating to the methodology and procedures followed for the collection/ estimation of data on land use, cropping and yields and suggest measures for improvement and
(b) assess the potential of remote sensing techniques to collect these data and to indicate how to utilize this potential and
(c) suggest institutional framework for improvement of agricultural statistics.

The Committee submitted its interim report to the Department in July, 2010 on the deficiencies in the existing system alongwith recommendations to ensure reliable, unbiased and timely estimates of area and yield for crops at the National and State level.

The Report has brought out that the deficiencies in the current system of both area and yield estimation arises from serious lacuna in institutional arrangements to collect, supervise and validate basic data on large scale on diverse crops. The Committee recommended the need for reducing the sample size by improving the design and bringing organizational changes to ensure tighter management and maintenance of high professional standards. The Report has recommended a two-pronged strategy (a) expanding the use of remote sensing as an independent source of land use, crop area and, to the extent possible, yield estimates, (b) restructuring the scope, organization and management of existing system of collecting primary data.

The Committee has recommended the creation of (a) National Crop Statistics Centre (NCSC) as an autonomous professionally run organization fully funded by the Centre to design, organise and supervise the generation of crop area and yield estimates at the State and National level. Fieldwork would be done by the trained staff in the state bureaus appointed and dedicated exclusively to carry out the programme decided by NCSC and their cost being borne entirely out of the Central Budget. 

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

DoT extends tenure of Patil committee

  • The Telecom Ministry on Wednesday extended till January 31 the tenure of the one-man committee under retired Supreme Court judge Justice Shivraj V. Patil which is looking into the appropriateness of procedures followed in issuance of licences during 2001-2009.
  • The government auditor CAG had alleged that several operators had suppressed information while applying for licences in 2007 to bag licences and 2G spectrum from former telecom minister A. Raja. The CAG has quantified revenue loss at a whopping presumptive Rs. 1.76 lakh crore due to the 2G spectrum scam.
  • During 2001-04, the BJP-led NDA government was at the Centre. Mr. Raja had been saying that he had only followed the policies of his predecessors. He was forced to resign last month in the wake of CAG report that put the revenue loss to the exchequer at Rs. 1.76 lakh crore for distributing licences in 2008 at 2001 prices

Friday, January 7, 2011

Srikrishna Committee comes out with six options

  • The Justice Srikrishna Committee, which held wide consultations in the last 11 months on demands for a separate State of Telangana as well as for keeping Andhra Pradesh united, has offered half-a-dozen options on which the government may take a call in about six weeks.
  • The suggestions include keeping Andhra Pradesh in the present form, forming a separate Telangana, and making Hyderabad a Union Territory, the sources said.
  • An extensive examination of the socio-economic factors in all regions of the State led the committee to conclude that there was no material basis for treating only the Telangana districts as "backward"

Friday, December 31, 2010

Krishna Water Disputes tribunal award

  • The Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal-II in its final award, announced here on Thursday, has placed certain restrictions on the three riparian States in keeping with the assessment of the yearly yield of river waters on which the allocations were made.
  • The Tribunal allocated 1,001 thousand million cubic feet (tmcft) of Krishna waters to Andhra Pradesh, 911 tmcft to Karnataka and 666 tmcft to Maharashtra. 
  • It also allowed Karnataka to raise the water level in the Almatti dam to 524.256 metres from the current level of 519.6 metres. Karnataka shall release 8 tmcft to 10 tmcft to Andhra Pradesh from the reservoir in June and July as regulated releases.
  • In the KWDT-II award, the Tribunal decided to distribute the Krishna river waters yield at 65 per cent dependability which was assessed at 2293 tmcft. In KWDT-I, the water yield was assessed at 75 per cent dependability yield assessed at 2173 tmcft.
  • While directing the States to prepare 10 daily working tables and the Rule Curve to work out the utilisation of water allocation "strictly in accordance with the order," the Tribunal said Andhra Pradesh should not utilise more than the 1,001 tmcft allocated to it in an average year. This includes a further allocation of 9 tmc for the Jurala Project, 25 tmc for the Telugu Ganga project and 150 tmcft for the carryover storage in the Srisailam and Nagarjuna Sagar dams. These restrictions are inclusive of evaporation losses. "So far as the remaining water is concerned, as may be available, that may also be utilised by Andhra Pradesh, subject to any part of it being stored/trapped in future and/or till the next review," the order said.
  • Karnataka shall not utilise more than 360 tmcft from the K-8 Tungabhadra sub-basin in a 65 per cent dependable water year or in an average water year. This will include allocation of 40 tmcft for the Upper Tunga, Upper Bhadra and Singatalur projects. The State shall not utilise more than 198 tmcft in a 65 per cent dependable water year and not more than 303 tmcft in an average water year from the Upper Krishna project, including an allocation of 130 tmcft for Upper Krishna Project State-III with the reservoir level of the Almatti dam at 524.256 metres.
  • Karnataka shall not utilise more than 799 tmcft in a 65 per cent dependable water year and not more than 904 tmcft in an average water year.
  • Maharashtra shall not utilise more than 98 tmcft in a 65 per cent dependable water year, including 3 tmcft allocated for the Kukadi Complex and 123 tmcft in an average water year from the Bhima sub-basin (K-5).
  • The State shall not divert more than 92.5 tmcft, including that allowed by KWDT-I and further 25 tmcft allowed under KWDT-II, from the K-1 Upper Krishna sub-basin for the Koyna Hydel station for westward diversion in a 65 per cent dependable or average water year.
  • Maharashtra shall not utilise more than 628 tmcft in a 65 per cent dependable year and not more than 663 tmcft in an average water year.The State has been restrained form diverting any water out of the basin, except from what has been allowed under the two awards.

Friday, December 24, 2010

One-man panel seeks documents from DoT on spectrum allocation

The one-man committee, looking into policies and procedures followed by the Telecom Ministry, has asked DoT for information on various issues including allocation of spectrum to all operators between 2001 and 2009.

The Justice Shivraj Patil committee was set up by Telecom Minister Kapil Sibal to look into the policies and suggest if they were followed in a transparent manner.

Justice Patil, a retired Supreme Court judge, has also asked for documents explaining circumstances under which the new National Telecom Policy was formulated in 1999 and subsequent introduction of the fourth cellular mobile licence in 2001.

He has also sought information about National Frequency Allocation Plan (NFAP), under which spectrum is allocated to operators, as revised from time to time.

Mr. Patil had earlier said that his mandate was limited to look into procedures followed by the DoT and not to investigate in the alleged 2G spectrum scam.

The panel is expected to complete the inquiry in four to five weeks and give its report to Mr. Sibal.

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

Srikrishna panel report on December 31

The committee headed by the former Supreme Court Judge, Justice B.N. Srikrishna, set up to go into the demands for a 'separate Telangana' State and a 'united Andhra Pradesh,' will present its report to the Centre on December 31, last day of its term.

The committee was appointed on February 3 this year, and some of its terms of reference are: to review the developments in Andhra Pradesh since its formation and their impact on the progress and development of the different regions; to examine the impact of the recent developments in the State on women, children, students, minorities, OBCs, SCs and STs; to consult all sections of the people, especially political parties, and elicit their views; to seek from the political parties and other organisations solutions to resolve the present difficult situation and promote the welfare of all sections of people.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Tandon Committee report on deemed universities

  • The committee invited all deemed-to-be-universities for presentations and face-to-face discussions in August and September 2009 in four sessions. A total of 126 institutions attended these sessions. The committee had sent questionnaires seeking all relevant information to these institutions well in advance.On the basis of their responses, the committee submitted its report on October 20, 2009
  • Tandon Committee found several aberrations in the functioning of these universities. The committee concluded that only 38 of these universities justified their continuation as "deemed universities"; 44 institutions were deficient in some aspects, which needed to be rectified over a three-year period; and, finally, 44 institutions neither on past performance nor on their promise for the future had the attributes to retain their status as deemed-to-be-universities. Sixteen of these 44 institutions are in Tamil Nadu.
  • The committee found "undesirable management architecture" where families rather than professional academics controlled the functioning of institutions. Several institutions were engaged in thoughtless introduction of unrelated programmes and proliferation of degrees beyond the mandate of the original terms of grant of deemed-to-be-university status. It also found very little evidence of noticeable efforts by some institutions in regard with emerging areas of knowledge.
  • With the notable exception of some publicly funded institutions, very few institutions could produce evidence of "quality" research in terms of publications in leading high-impact journals in respective fields.
  • Lack of commitment towards research and irresponsible exercise of power with regard to admission, intake capacity, programmes and fee structure were found to be other attributes of such institutions. Many of these, which were once colleges, increased their intake capacity disproportionately and in some cases exponentially in relation to the qualified faculty strength and other academic infrastructure.
  • In several institutions, undergraduate and postgraduate programmes had been fragmented with concocted nomenclatures. Several institutions have prescribed fee structures considerably higher than those recommended by the official fee structure committees.
  • The Tandon Committee members also became members of the task force constituted by the Centre on November 16, 2009, to prepare an action plan to safeguard the interests of students enrolled in institutions whose deemed-to-be-university status was proposed to be revoked in the public interest. The task force recommended that all pre-existing colleges not found suitable for the status of deemed-to-be-university should revert to the status quo ante as an affiliated college of the State university so that students would be able to complete their ongoing courses and obtain degrees from the affiliating university.
  • Where an institution is unable to obtain affiliation, it suggested that every effort should be made to facilitate migration or re-enrolment of students to equivalent or similar courses in other institutions.
  • The task force made it clear that the entire cost of migration and rehabilitation of affected students should be at the expense of the managements of the failed institutions and must come from the corpus fund that was required to be maintained in respect of each under UGC guidelines.
  • Centre accepted the reports of the Tandon Committee and the task force. The announcement led to widespread concern and unrest among the students of these universities. The right course for the Centre might have been to place these reports in the public domain, invite public response, and then take a decision.

Monday, December 6, 2010

Recommendations of N.C. Saxena Committee

Dr. N.C. Saxena Committee was set up by the Ministry of Rural Development to advise it on the suitable methodology for BPL Census and not for estimation of poverty. However, in the Report submitted by the Expert Group on 21st August 2009 it is mentioned that the percentage of people entitled to BPL status should be revised upwards to at least 50%. The committee has suggested proportionate increase in the state level poverty estimates also.

The recommendations of the Expert Group and other alternative methodologies are being tested through a pilot socio-economic survey and a Participatory Rural Appraisal (PRA) exercise in order to finalize the methodology for the final BPL Census.


Dr. Bimal Jalan committee report on ownership and governance of the Market Infrastructure Institutions

SEBI, in January 2010, had appointed a committee under Dr. Bimal Jalan (former Governor of the Reserve Bank of India) to study and recommend changes on the ownership and governance of the Market Infrastructure Institutions ("MIIs") like stock exchanges, depositaries and clearing corporations. The committee, on November 22, 2010, has submitted its report ("Report") to SEBI and is available for public comments. The report makes some particularly strong recommendations including not allowing such entities to get listed on stock exchanges.

The Report examines the nature of these institutions and the reasons for such institutions being referred to as MIIs in the light of doctrines like 'Essential Facilities', 'Natural Monopolies', 'Economies of Scale' and emphasizes on the systematic importance of these MIIs for the economy. The report views these MIIs as producers of public good and says that '….. the three MIIs in the securities holding-trading-clearing-settlement chain are engaged in the business of producing a valuable public good for society, which are essentially the price signals produced by a transparent and efficient market mechanism'.

The Report says that it is not possible to sever the regulatory role of the MIIs from their more obvious role of serving as providers of infrastructure of the market and goes on to describe the characteristics and functions of these MIIs emphasizing the following characteristics of such institutions:-

  1. In general, MIIs are in the nature of public utilities.
  2. All of them are vested with regulatory responsibilities, in varying degrees.
  3. They have systemic importance to the economy.

In the above background, the Report highlights the conflict in the 'regulatory role' of these MIIs with their 'economic interests'.

The key recommendations in the Report are the following:

1. Changes to Securities Contracts (Manner of Increasing and Maintaining Public Shareholding in Recognised Stock Exchanges) Regulations, 2006: The Committee has proposed the replacement of these regulations by a comprehensive set of regulations on the ownership and governance of stock exchange. By way of a transit, the committee recommends changes for the existing provisions of these regulations which inter-alia contains a recommendation that- ' All anchor institutional investors put together shall not hold more than 49% of the total equity capital of an exchange'. Currently depositories, clearing corporations, banks, insurers and public financial institutions are allowed to hold, individually, up to 15% in a stock exchange.

2. Ownership and Control of a MII in another classes of MII: As regards the ownership and control of MII, the committee has proposed the following:

  • Clearing Corporations and Depositories may not be allowed to invest in other class of MIIs .
  • at least 51% of the paid-up equity capital of the Clearing Corporation should be held by one or more recognised Stock Exchanges.
  • the holding of stock exchanges in depositories may be restricted to a maximum of 24%.
  • In case of all MIIs, FIIs should be allowed to acquire the shares through off market transactions including through initial allotment, as allowed for any other shareholders, subject to the limits specified by the Government from time to time.

3. Governance of MIIs: As regards the governance of MIIs, the committee has proposed the following:

Stock Exchanges:

  • no trading /clearing member (irrespective of exchange where he operates) shall be allowed on the board of any of the stock exchange
  • the number of public interest directors ("PIDs") on the board of a stock exchange shall at least be equal to the number of shareholder directors without trading/ clearing interest.

    Clearing Corporations:

  • the number of PIDs on the board of a clearing corporation shall at least be equal to the number of shareholder directors without trading/clearing interest.

    Depositories:

  • same as prescribed for listed companies under clause 49 of the listing agreement.

4. Disclosures by board members of MIIs: All transactions in securities of the board members of the MII and their family have to be disclosed to the board of the MII.

5. Disclosure and corporate governance requirements: The committee recommends that the disclosures and corporate governance requirements of the listing agreement applicable to listed companies shall be made applicable to MIIs too. The information required to be disclosed under the listing agreement should be posted on the website of the MII.

6. Mandatory appointment of Compliance Officers: SEBI has mandated various registered intermediaries and also depositaries to appoint a compliance officer to ensure that the intermediary complies with the rules, regulations, circulars and directives of SEBI. The committee recommends that such appointment should be made mandatory also for the stock exchanges and clearing corporation.

7. No listing of these MIIs: The committee is not in favour of listing of MIIs and observes that- '... MII should not become a vehicle for attracting speculative investments. Further, MIIs being public institutions, any downward movement in its share prices may lead to a loss of credibility and this may be detrimental to the market as a whole'.

8. Networth Requirements: The committee recommends that Stock Exchanges should have a net worth of INR 100 crores at all times. As regards depositories, the SEBI prescribed net worth of INR 100 crores is suggested to be retained with a rider that '…all other investments in related, unrelated/other business shall be excluded while computing the net worth'. For clearing corporation, the committee recommends an ongoing net-worth requirement of INR 300 crores in the form of liquid assets.

Apart from above, a recommendation in the report which may cause significant outcry is putting of a cap on the maximum return that can be earned by MII on its net worth and can be distributed / allocated to its shareholders. The committee observes '…MII being a public utility should endeavor to earn only reasonable profits at par with average earnings of the corporate sector in India'.

It would be interesting to see how much of these recommendations are implemented by the regulator. These recommendations are seen as a disappointment and have been met with criticism on the lines that it would protect the monopolistic market structure and perverse anti-competitive practices by some and prevent new entrants on the stock exchange space. Also, the buzz in media is that the government is unsure of implementing these recommendations.